| 1 | All You Need Is Love | 4:09 | 4:09 | Live Collaboration |
| 5 | Ants Marching | 4:40 | 3:16 | Under the Table and Dreaming |
| 1 | Anyone Seen the Bridge | | | Segues |
| 3 | Bartender | 7:36 | 5:13 | Busted Stuff |
| 1 | Beach Ball | 3:51 | 3:51 | Misc Release |
| 1 | Break for It | 5:08 | 5:08 | Unreleased |
| 4 | Crush | 5:55 | 5:33 | Before These Crowded Streets |
| 2 | Dancing Nancies | 4:34 | 4:34 | Under the Table and Dreaming |
| 1 | Dive In | 4:01 | 4:01 | Big Whiskey and the GrooGrux King |
| 1 | Do You Remember | 4:00 | 4:00 | Come Tomorrow |
| 1 | Don't Drink the Water | | | Before These Crowded Streets |
| 1 | Everyday | | | Everyday |
| 1 | Funny the Way It Is | | | Big Whiskey and the GrooGrux King |
| 2 | Grace Is Gone | 3:54 | 3:54 | Busted Stuff |
| 3 | Grey Street | 5:18 | 4:17 | Busted Stuff |
| 1 | I Can See Clearly Now | 3:04 | 3:04 | Cover Songs |
| 1 | Lie in Our Graves | | | Crash |
| 1 | The Maker | 4:18 | 4:18 | Cover Songs |
| 1 | Mercy | 2:27 | 2:27 | Away from the World |
| 1 | Minarets | 5:12 | 5:12 | Remember Two Things |
| 3 | The Ocean and the Butterfly | 3:11 | 2:55 | Walk Around the Moon |
| 1 | Oh | 2:51 | 2:51 | Dave Matthews - Some Devil |
| 1 | Raven | 2:39 | 2:39 | Busted Stuff |
| 1 | Rooftop | 3:21 | 3:21 | Away from the World |
| 2 | Satellite | 2:52 | 2:52 | Under the Table and Dreaming |
| 5 | Save Me | 4:55 | 3:27 | Dave Matthews - Some Devil |
| 5 | Singing From the Windows | 4:13 | 3:22 | Walk Around the Moon |
| 1 | Sledgehammer | | | Cover Songs |
| 3 | So Damn Lucky | 4:32 | 4:22 | Dave Matthews - Some Devil |
| 1 | So Much to Say | | | Crash |
| 2 | The Space Between | 3:22 | 3:22 | Everyday |
| 2 | Stay or Leave | 3:54 | 3:54 | Dave Matthews - Some Devil |
| 1 | Take Me to Tomorrow | 4:19 | 4:19 | Cover Songs |
| 1 | Too Much | | | Crash |
| 1 | Tripping Billies | 3:52 | 3:52 | Crash |
| 1 | Two Step | 5:06 | 5:06 | Crash |
| 1 | Up and Away | 3:28 | 3:28 | Dave Matthews - Some Devil |
| 1 | Virginia in the Rain | 4:06 | 4:06 | Come Tomorrow |
| 1 | Warehouse | 7:24 | 7:24 | Under the Table and Dreaming |
| 1 | When the World Ends | | | Everyday |
| 2 | Where Are You Going | 3:37 | 3:37 | Busted Stuff |
| 1 | Why I Am | | | Big Whiskey and the GrooGrux King |
| 1 | You & Me | | | Big Whiskey and the GrooGrux King |
| 1 | You Never Know | 5:18 | 5:18 | Busted Stuff |